The suspense surrounding the death of Anthony Fox has kept *Emmerdale* fans on the edge of their seats. 

After weeks of tension, shocking twists, and numerous suspects, the identity of the person responsible for Anthony’s gruesome demise has finally been pieced together by fans. 

And to everyone’s surprise, it’s not one of the obvious suspects, but rather a character from the past who returns to the village to settle an old score.

Anthony’s death was always bound to spark speculation, especially after the revelation of his despicable past, 

which involved the sexual abuse of his daughter Ruby Miligan when she was a teenager. 

The devastating truth about Ruby’s childhood, coupled with the shock that Anthony had fathered Ruby’s daughter Steph, set the stage for an explosive conclusion to his story. 

As the weeks went on, fans were led through a thrilling “whodunnit” plot, with numerous characters including Caleb Miligan, Cain Dingle, and even Aaron Dingle, all being considered as potential suspects.

The tension reached its peak when viewers saw Anthony bloodied and lifeless on the depot floor in a flash-forward. This moment left fans reeling and desperate to know who was responsible for the murder. Many predicted that Caleb, whose anger toward his father-in-law had been building after learning the truth about Ruby and Steph, would be the one to kill Anthony. Others thought Aaron or Cain might be involved, given their connections to the case.

However, in a twist that took many by surprise, fans have begun to point the finger at a past character who has been missing from the show for some time. Speculation started to rise when Nicky Miligan, Ruby and Caleb’s son, was mentioned in a recent episode. His name was brought up by Steph, and this brief mention sent fans into a frenzy, wondering if Nicky might return to the village to take revenge on his grandfather, Anthony.

While Nicky has been absent from the village for a while, many viewers have pointed out that his absence only adds to the intrigue. Could Nicky have learned the truth about Anthony’s abuse of his mother, Ruby? If so, it would make sense for him to return and seek vengeance. Fans have expressed their excitement over the possibility of Nicky being the one to kill Anthony, with one viewer commenting, “I was kind of hoping there would be a twist and it was actually Nicky that came back and did it.” Another fan echoed the sentiment, saying, “I would love Nicky back for this storyline actually. Imagine he’s actually the one that kills Anthony.”

The theory that Nicky could be the killer has gained traction on social media, with fans discussing the potential impact of his return on the storyline. Many believe that Nicky’s return would add an extra layer of emotional weight to the already intense drama. After all, he would have a personal reason to seek justice for his mother, Ruby, who was the victim of Anthony’s cruel actions. In this scenario, Nicky’s return could be the catalyst for a long-awaited moment of reckoning for Anthony.

Another key factor in the theory is the ongoing drama surrounding Steph, who is unaware of the truth about her biological father. Some fans have suggested that once Steph finds out the horrifying truth about Anthony, she could play a pivotal role in pushing Nicky to act. Could Steph’s discovery of the truth lead to a confrontation between her and Anthony, sparking a violent altercation that ultimately leads to his death? Fans will have to wait to see how this storyline unfolds, but the potential for drama is undeniable.

As the murder mystery continues to develop, one thing is clear: the truth behind Anthony’s death is likely to be more complicated than anyone first imagined. While many fans believed that Caleb, Cain, or Aaron would be the one to kill Anthony, the possibility that a past character like Nicky could return to take justice into their own hands adds a whole new layer to the plot.

As the days go by, *Emmerdale* fans are eager to see how this storyline plays out. Will Nicky Miligan make a dramatic return to the village, and if so, will he be the one to kill Anthony? Only time will tell, but one thing is for sure: the mystery of Anthony Fox’s death is far from over, and viewers can expect plenty of twists and turns before the final revelation.

Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.